Cops are called to a house in the affluent neighborhood of Mclean, VA. It's the home of Pamela Hargan and appeared to be a murder/suicide, but when someone from across the country reveals they were the 911 caller, the investigation takes a shocking turn. Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for mer…

Trigger Warning - this episodes contains child abuse On May 7, 2007, a man in the small town of Kurim, Czech Republic had just set up a new video baby monitor, but when he turned it on, he didn't see his newborn baby. Instead, the signal had crossed with a neighbor and he saw probably one of the most horrific things you can imagine...Thank God for …

F YEAH TO 100 EPISODES! We're switching it up for the special occasion! Rebecca talks about 4 separate unexplainable stories: John "Fritz" Johnson, a local legend in Omaha, NE gets confronted by stranger in Chicago and his life(s) is forever changed. David Glenn Lewis: In 1993, David's wife and daughter went on a shopping trip for the weekend and c…

In 1990, a local news anchor named Diane Newton King got a phone call from a fan asking for advice. She was polite and talked to him, but then he kept calling...Things went downhill fast. This was the beginning of stalking laws and Diane's husband Brad was a former cop so they took this very seriously. Then on a cold, February night it all ended tr…

*DISCLAIMER - Rebecca's an idiot and forgot to connect her microphone to our recording platform so she sounds more echoey than usual. You would think after 98 episodes, we would have this down but you'd be wrong. On October 1, 1985, 17-year-old Michele "Missy" Avila went out with her friend, Laura Doyle. Hours later, the Avila's phone rings and it'…

Joan Harmon had had a very rough couple of years until 2004 when she met & married Christian "Kit" Martin. Kit was a well respected army major and when the two finally settled in Pembroke, Kentucky, life was good...until it wasn't. After their divorce, Cal & Pam Phillips take Joan in until she gets back on her feet. As she's moving out, she finds s…

In 2002, John Darwin went out for an early morning kayak ride and never returned. His wife and two sons were devastated but held out hope that he was alive until his broken kayak washed up on shore months later. It was determined he was dead but they never found a body. Six years later a man walks into a police station and changes the entire invest…

On January 11, 2018, 55-year-old Ray Wright vanished without a trace. He had no reason to leave. After all, his family said he was in the best place of his life. Fearing the worst, his brother went to his house to check on him and walked in on an intruder. A few days later, Sacramento police were led on a high speed chase, seemingly unrelated to Ra…

In 2006, 17-year-old Ashley Reeves borrowed her boyfriends car for a job interview then had plans to play basketball with friends, but she never came home. A missing persons report was filed and her friends tell police a secret that Ashley was keeping that leads them right to someone no one expected...and he is the absolute worst. Produced by Jacob…

In 2008, police in Raleigh, NC received reports of an unresponsive woman on the side of the interstate. When they got there, it was clear that 21-year-old Latrese Curtis had been brutally murdered. Latrese was a newlywed and college student who had a secret that nobody knew about. When investigators uncover the secret, they zero in on multiple susp…

The Facebook Rapist, Thabo Bester. Get a load of this sh*t. Story starts on 4:28 Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instagram & YouTubeBleav

1999, Stacie Reed & Kristie Reed, were brutally attacked after returning home from school. Stacie's friend, Paul Powell, was arrested and when we talk about people being the worst, he's up there. After sending taunting letters to the victims' families & the prosecutor, it's clear he thinks he is the smartest one in the room, but don't worry, his ac…

9-year-old Annie Swartz woke up to what sounded like a struggle downstairs. She froze in fear when she heard her dad yell for help but before she knew it, there was silence. Once the door slammed, she looked out the window to see a man with an axe walking into the woods. Based on the description, police were confident they knew who it was but they …

In 1996, 18-year-old Angie Dodge was found murdered in her Idaho Falls, ID apartment. Fortunately, they had a perfect DNA sample. Unfortunately, things were mishandled. Someone was charged relatively quickly, but was it the right person? It takes over two decades (and CeCe Moore, duh) to find out & this story doesn't end there. Listen to this case …

On January 13th, 2010 a policeman driving around Conyers, GA heard screams of 2 young girls. It was 16-year-old identical twins, Jasmiyah and Tasmiyah Whitehead, who just came home from school to a gruesome crime scene. Their mother, Nikki, was found in her bathrub stabbed over 80 times after a very clear struggle. There's no shortage of suspects b…

In 2010, Yara Gambirasio went to run a quick errand and never returned home. Her small, safe Italian town of Brembate di Sopra was shaken when it wasn't immediately solved. Luckily, the lead investigator was a badass who wouldn't give up. Her hunt for the killer unveiled several secrets and made this one of the most expensive & controversial cases …

Tanya Kach was going through a rebellious stage when her parents got divorced and her dad moved her to Mckeesport, PA. Middle school is a terrible time to be a new student and she struggled to make friends. She would often run away only to come home a few hours later and in February 1996, her dad and stepmom woke up to what they assumed was one of …

Susie Newsom was born into a very prominent family in North Carolina. When she was in college, she met her future husband Tom Lynch. They got married, had two sons & Tom started his own dental practice. However, Susie was miserable and when the marriage fell apart, she started behaving differently, to say the least. After she sparked up a new roman…

”We imagine someone’s last moments in the hands of evil beyond terrifying when, in fact, the person is protected by shock. While in this state, pain is not felt and the greatest escape at that time is to cross over. When it happened to me I did not feel like I died. In fact I had never felt more alive in my life. I knew everything and feared nothin…

Jamie & Jennifer Faith had been together for almost 15 years when one day, Jennifer randomly got a message from her old high school boyfriend, Darrin Lopez. Jennifer & Darrin hadn't talked in over 30 years, but soon they were texting each other all day every day...and the communication got spicy. Even though Jennifer was married and everyone seemin…

Imagine finding out you were kidnapped and not having any answers for 40+ years. Come on this roller coaster of emotions as Rebecca tells the fascinating and devastating story of Paul Fronczak. *Story starts minute 3:22 Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instag…

On May 23, 1984, over a dozen people on a quiet street were awoken by a scream in the middle of the night, yet nobody knew where it came from so nobody called the cops. The next morning, 36-year-old Karen Gregory's was found horrifically murdered. This case is a real whodunnit and after two years, they finally bring the shocking perpetrator to just…

Margy Palm was kidnapped from a KMart while Christmas shopping in San Antonio, TX. After several hours of being held hostage the kidnapper made her go into a 7-eleven to pick up a few things and she sees a startling headline that makes her realize how much danger she's actually in. The thing is though: she wasn't planning that trip to KMart. It was…

When 36-year-old single dad, Dave Kroupa, decided to start dating again after breaking up with his long term girlfriend, he was hesitant to start anything serious. That's why he was relieved when he met Cari Farver, who also wanted to keep the relationship casual...Until one day when she abruptly suggested that they live together. When Dave said no…

Stephen Schap was a family-oriented man who swore that if he ever got married, it would be for life. Divorce was not an option for him but unfortunately it was for his wife, Diane, and in 1993 she made it clear that she wanted one. Stephen took it surprisingly well...until he didn’t. Things went south very quickly and the victim isn't who you think…

You're getting 3 stories today! Nadja Medley and her daughter Payton were living in Ogden, UT when Nadja met the love of her life, Mike Bullinger. However, Nadja was concerned that Mike wasn't as committed to her as she was to him so to prove it, Mike bought a ranch in Caldwell, Idaho and asked Nadja and Payton to move in with him. It was a happily…

In 1984, a huge fire at Ole's Home Center in Pasadena, CA took the lives of 4 people. This was only one of the estimated 2,000 fires in the 80s and early 90s started by a serial arsonist known as the Pillow Pyro. A dedicated task force was formed to catch him, and when they zeroed in on the most unlikely suspect, it spurred a badass investigation. …

Jesse Valencia was a fun-loving, sociable college student at University of Missouri and had a ton of friends so when he was found outside nearly naked with his throat slit, the entire college town was shocked. While there were a ton of suspects, the investigation reveals a secret that would lead them right to Jesse's unexpected killer. Produced by …

Natalie Bollinger and her twin sister Alycia had a difficult childhood. During a particularly rough part of their early teenage years, Natalie struck up a friendship with a much older homeless man named Shawn Schwartz. When they had a falling out & Natalie cut off all ties, Shawn didn't take it well. She posted a very public Facebook status about h…

Christi Flynn was at a bar one night when 3 men walked in and started harassing her. She managed to get away from them but as she was putting her key in her car door, they attacked her. This was the beginning of a 3 against 1 night of torture and Christi comes out on top but sadly there was another victim who wasn't as lucky. Learn how she got away…

In 1998, the Australian town of Rockhampton was shaken when 14 year old Natasha Ryan went missing. Soon after her disappearance, 4 others went missing and were ultimately determined to be murdered. All the while, a monster named Leonard Fraser was terrorizing the area, so police were confident they had their guy. Leonard was arrested & charged with…

36-year-old Dana Laskowksi was described as a nurturing woman who loved life and, despite the challenges of being a single mom to 9-year-old triplets, she was the type of person who opened her home to whoever needed it. This is why everyone was shocked when she was found twisted and contorted in a very unnatural position, strangled to death... but …

In 2005, 18-year-old Noura Jackson came home after a night out to find her mom, Jennifer, had been stabbed 50 times. Sadly, Noura had experienced this before when her dad was murdered about 18 months prior. Justice is eventually served but is the evidence enough to ensure that the right person went to prison? This one is baffling. Produced by Jacob…

in 2017 Sabrina Kouider and Ouissem (Sam) Medouni were trying to make a name for themselves in London and dreamed of being apart of the celeb/socialite scene. The young couple decided to hire Sophie Lionnet as an au pair to take care of their young children but they soon realize she's not who she says she is....OR were Sam and Sabrina deeply delusi…

Bart Corbin & Jennifer Barber started dating in 1996 and things got serious quickly when she found out she was pregnant, but they made it work! They got married, had two healthy boys, Bart had a thriving dental practice - life was good...for a little while. Each of them had secrets and after an apparent suicide, a huge secret comes to light leading…

In the final part of the Natalee Holloway case, we discuss another sting operation involving a man name John Ludwick, who claims he helped Joran move Natalee's body in 2010, 5 years after her disappearance. We also tell you about Joran's prison antics in Peru, the long overdue extradition to Birmingham, Alabama and the current status of his extorti…

Part 3 of the Natalee Holloway case picks up in 2007. Natalee had been missing for 2 years and while living in the Netherlands for college, Joran meets a man who befriends him with the sole mission of taking him down. His "friend", along with badass crime reporter Peter de Vries, record Joran confessing to what really happened to Natalee. We discus…

In part 2 of Natalee's case, we continue with how the investigation is going in Aruba during the summer of 2005 and what is going on back in Birmingham during that time. We also discuss the awful disappearance of Amy Bradley and why her story renewed our hope that Natalee may still be alive. Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh Join our Patreon for bonus e…

As 2 people who knew Natalee we wanted to bring a more personal perspective to this story. Natalee Holloway went on her senior trip in 2005 and never came back. While we all know who is responsible, it’s been 18-years and she still hasn’t been found. Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, …

Lori Slesinski was valedictorian of her high school and an Auburn University grad when she went missing without a trace. She had a ton of friends but one in particular had a sinister past no one knew about... Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instagram & YouTu…

In 1984, a beloved minister, husband & father of two was found murdered. The people of Clinton, North Carolina were shocked...but they didn't know what was happening behind closed doors. Not one, but two secret lives are revealed & there's finally justice for this horrific crime two years later. There are so many twists in this one that Rachel had …

Sandra Boss was killing it in New York City making $2M a year when she met Clark Rockefeller (yes, THE Rockefellers). They got married and had a daughter, who they nicknamed “Snooks” and Clark was in love with her. But when Snooks gets kidnapped things start unraveling and Clark’s sketchy past finally catches up to him Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh …

In December 2003, the Whitaker family went to dinner to celebrate the oldest son, Bart's, college graduation. The joyful night turned to terror when they got home to find a gunman hiding inside who fired at them one by one as they walked in the door. Over the next 14 months, a tangled web of lies & betrayal unravel and even though they figure out w…

If you like a “whodunit” this one’s for you! Linda Slaten is a single mom raising 2 boys. Less than two weeks after moving into an apartment in Lakeland, Florida she was found brutally murdered. There are a lot of viable suspects but the killer managed to fly under the radar and live a completely normal life for 40 YEARS after his disgusting crime.…

Sam Herr & Julie Kibuishi met at Orange Coast College & became good friends. On May 22, 2010, nobody could get in touch with either of them, so Sam's dad went to his apartment and made a very gruesome discovery that led to a murder investigation and a huge manhunt. The cops think they found the accomplice who helped the killer get away, but they qu…

Carolands Mansion was once considered the 2nd largest house in America. Built in 1912 on 554 acres in Hillsborough, CA, the impressive estate had 100+ rooms and was almost considered to be the West Coast White House but by 1975 it was abandon and slid into serious decline. It was rumored amongst high schoolers that security guards would give unoffi…

In 1985, 18 year old Stacie Pannell was found dead in her college dorm room. While police zero in on a suspect, the real killer flies under their radar and the way they’re caught is truly fascinating. Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instagram & YouTube Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh…

Reid Gray came home from work to find a ransom note from 3 men who had his wife captive. This starts a 3 day nightmare and will end up changing the couples lives forever. This is the bizarre kidnapping of Quinn Gray. Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instagram & YouTube Produced by Jacob …

In 1997, Judy Smith went to Philadelphia with her husband Jeffrey so he could attend a work conference. While he was at the conference, Judy went sightseeing, and mysteriously vanished. There were several bizarre sightings of her in the area, but none of them panned out, leaving Jeffrey & her kids were baffled about where she could be. Months later…

Nick Alahverdian grew up jumping from abusive foster home to abusive foster home but he came out on the other side and as an adult he fought to change the foster care system —catching the attention of several high profile politicians, but Nick had a dirty secret that several people came forward about, and eventually the cops and even FBI wanted ans…