KJ and Meredith are joined by Ella (The Cas Cast) for this heavy-hitting episode. Sam, Dean, and Cas each have their own storylines, a frightening glimpse into the future of Supernatural and the task ahead of this podcast. There’s big news about Sam’s extracurriculars this week, leading to a serious conversation around the impact of hosting a demon…

KJ, August (Saving People, Queering Things), and Alyssa don’t get a holiday in this episode, but they do get to to recap this episode of Supernatural. KJ takes a hard stance on a hard truth about Dean, everyone forgets one of the key plots of this episode, and Pamela is dubbed an icon in her final episode. CW Episode Description: Sam and Dean inves…

In celebration of 100 recordings, 100 edits, and 100 of everything else it takes to put together a podcast episode, KJ and Meredith open the doors on their friendship origin story, answer some AMA questions, KJ comes clean about some secret shipping (not clickbait!), and KJ pitches some of her other hyper fixation shows to Meredith as potential fut…

Sex and Violence experts Beth and Hannah, along with their Raising Perdition co-host Abby Jo, help KJ and Meredith through this week’s episode where the doctor/coroner is an alcoholic, the siren is Judd from 9-1-1: Lone Star, and there’s uproar over censorship and a passionate plea to let Sam get laid, just not in this particular episode. In a shoc…

While KJ and Meredith met in school, you couldn’t pay them to go back there now. And yet, that’s what Sam and Dean are doing this week, so we’re bringing our guest Frances along for the ride and hoping for the best. KJ revels in some Sam comment, but admits that having Sam content at the expense of Dean’s character assassination might be too high a…

KJ and Meredith have brought in recurring guest, renowned fic-writer Jenn to talk about some monsters that didn’t find a place in 327 episodes, but should have. We talk overarching mythologies, specific monsters and locations, and other missed opportunities. Meredith’s been keeping a list of some primo monsters that the SPN writers overlooked and i…

Note: There’s a slight audio issue on this episode that resulted in some of the audio being a bit choppy, it appears to be a one-time problem, and we did what we could with it. KJ knows way too much about Criss Angel this week and Meredith, Ella (The Cas Cast) and JJ (jjbwaywatch) are all forced to listen to it. JJ rates this episode out of Taco Be…

Content warning to animal cruelty/death in this episode. We don’t want to talk about it either. As promised, KJ and Meredith are all alone this week to hustle through this episode and provide insights in a quick and efficient manner that leaves us dwelling on the hand-licking and dog dying for as little time as possible. As promised, KJ hates this …

KJ and Meredith are joined by Sarah as heaven and hell collide over Anna. Bobby’s wisely on vacation, something we all wish we were on. Sarah discredits one of Sam’s crowning moments with insightful interpretation and brings us an absolute bombshell deleted scene that KJ and Meredith have not seen before. CW Episode Description: Anna (guest star Ju…

KJ is joined by Meredith as well as the hosts of Idling in the Impala, Sandra and Kasey, where KJ finds company in the pro-Sam camp. A lot of information about Sam comes to light in this one, and the reinforcement was absolutely needed. We also get a lot of information about the actual mechanics of The Apocalypse™. Also new angels and demons drop, …

Have you ever invested significant emotions and time into a franchise only for a character who has spent all their screen time valiantly overcoming their demons to be struck down (maybe poetically, maybe just cruelly) in the final moments? Had all their character development undone for the sake of symmetry? (If you answer no, I've got bad news for …

Meredith’s away so KJ and Frances will play- aka talk about this wacky episode of Supernatural where Sam dies and no one even remembers it happening. There’s a lot of out of pocket events in this episode for KJ and Frances to riff on including the denouncement of Bigfoot in the Supernatural universe. Sam and Dean also go for a record number of diff…

Sam and Cas are finally meeting, so it’s fitting that KJ and Meredith are meeting a brand new guest this week, Tessy! The group wonders where Cas has been if so many seals have been breaking, and makes some suggestions on how Heaven might better communicate with the Winchester. A complaint is lodged directly to Eric Kripke about a recurring narrati…

KJ and Meredith are joined by fellow podcaster Katie (Making It Up As We Go: A Destiel Fanfic Anthology Podcast) to talk about fears in this week’s episode of Supernatural. Dean’s infected with ghost sickness and we get a glimpse into some of his deepest fears. KJ argues **gasp** that Sam is just as much of a jerk as Dean and should have been infec…

KJ previously went on record in a bonus episode of Driver Picks the Podcast to rank this episode as one of their bottom five of the Kripke Era. This week, Beth and Jamie come aboard with KJ and Meredith to convince KJ that this episode is actually *art*. This episode is fun old-horror movie themed and the bottom line is that this episode works beca…

Supernatural Opinions goes to Torah study with Jen (The Judah Initiative Podcast) and Ben! KJ and Meredith are here to ask questions about the Jewish influence on Supernatural (ranging from thoughtful to just plain silly) to Jupernatural experts Jen and Ben. Major topics include (but aren’t limited to): the writer’s room, names, the real Lebanon, K…

Just when you thought Editing KJ had died (and this episode DID attempt to kill them!), KJ is back to spend yet another week diving deep into the CW network's walls. This week a bonus episode starring Meredith and August! Instead of notes, here's a list of corrections Editing KJ had of Recording KJ's words: Note that Kevin did in fact lose a kidney…

Special thank you to Noah (@podcatsedits on instagram) for editing this episode. KJ and Meredith are joined by a very fun duo of Kate and Bahy this week to talk about Kim Manners’ final episode of Supernatural. KJ has a regret about their extensive Supernatural statistics. Dean says if he didn’t know Sam, he’d want to hunt him, leading the squad to…

Special thank you to Noah (@podcatsedits on instagram) for editing this episode. KJ, Meredith, and Nick are time traveling and KJ is here to make even more Back to the Future references than this episode of Supernatural. KJ condemns Sam Winchester’s fashion tastes even though there’s a significant lack of Sam in this episode. The crew discusses the…

Special thank you to Noah (@podcatsedits on instagram) for editing this episode. KJ and Meredith are reunited, and join up with first time guest, Kaya, to talk about this episode of Supernatural where the biblical Apocalypse is introduced. KJ takes issue with the writer’s guest character selection, and the crew agrees with the Winchesters that Bobb…

Special thank you to Noah (@podcatsedits on instagram) for editing this episode. KJ starts the new season hot out of the gate with a discussion on Jesus vs Lazarus. But they’re not on this journey alone, August (Saving People, Queering Things) and Pluto. Cas is finally here, the show finally takes a firm anti-incest stance, and a guest appearance b…

Just ahead of the introduction of Misha's characeracer Castiel to the podcast, we take a quick (or not so quick) look at one of Misha's post-Supernatural characters, folklore professor Jeremy Bradshaw. The stars are aligning after months of delay and KJ and Meredith are kicking off the new season with Frances to talk about Bridgewater Season 2 just…

KJ and Meredith reflect on the shortest season of Supernatural before putting it behind them forever, analyze some of KJ’s stats, and answer some listener questions about season 3. Linktree including sign up sheet to be on the podcast and our Discord server: https://linktr.ee/SupernaturalOpinionsPodcast For more KJ Spn-verse content check out KJ’s …

It’s a Pod Squad roundup on the season 3 finale as KJ and Meredith are joined by August (Saving People, Queering Things), and Beth and Jamie (Driver Picks The Podcast, Thief Steals The Podcast). The squad struggles not to talk about Cas as his presence looms so closely. Also up for discussion is hellhounds on planes and financial compensation for B…

If you thought KJ’s death count was wacky during Mystery Spot, you’re not prepared for the math happening in the wake of Doc Benton. KJ, Meredith, and Frances are gathered this week to ask some questions about surgical practices. And Frances takes on the mythology section this week with some information about the urban legend that inspired this wee…

KJ, Meredith, and Katie (Making It Up As We Go) are recapping this episode and asking some very basic questions about this week’s monster that this episode and even Meredith’s mythology section don’t really have answers for. It’s an episode of fun facts where Kentucky is called out for naming it’s towns with pronunciations at odds with the rest of …

We were offered ice cream to not cover this episode and leave right now, but here we are. KJ, Meredith, Beth (Raising Perdition), and Out (Divergent Canon) discuss the Ghostfacers’ Effect, swearing in Supernatural, and the effects of time on this iconic episode of retro-TV-series-Supernatural. CW Episode Description: Sam and Dean take a break from …

KJ, Meredith, and Elayna (Saving People, Queering Things) host a summit on a character entirely unique to this season, and that is Bela Talbot. After a brief interlude to talk about that one angel that doesn’t even go here yet, they get to business talking about Supernatural’s best business woman! Along with Bela’s storyline, they also cover the ro…

Sam and Dean are in a tricky situation and KJ, Meredith, Nick, and Moira are here to berate the writers (looking at you Sera Gamble) for their handling of Winchester FBI File Holder Victor Henriksen. Ruby’s back, Sam’s bad at communications, and it’s our first time meeting Lilith. Everyone’s weird about sexual experiences, and there’s a loud speake…

“Honey, I rose up from the dead, I do it all the time” This podcast is back from the near-death caused by the WGA/SAG-AFTRA strike to talk about an episode of Supernatural where Dean just cannot stop dying. KJ, Meredith, Jenn, and Chi gathered to talk about Mystery Spot. We take a quick minute to talk about a writer who didn’t write this episode an…

KJ is rising from the dead as the SAG-AFTRA strike continues to drag on. This bonus, they're talking recording equipment and editing process. In addition: A brief update on the strike, and at the end, an announcement for a new project that KJ has been participating in that will be out Friday, November 10, 2023 as well as the details on where to fin…

One Editing KJ, still seeking additional editing support-reach out through social media DMs or supernaturalopinionspodcast@gmail.com for more info and to become KJ's personal saviour. WGA and SAG-AFTRA are still on strike against their employer AMPTP, so (Editing) KJ is here to share wisdom for future podcasting generations. Here be the basics you …

It's a quick note from Editing KJ with an update on the plan for the strike, a call out for some unpaid labor, and hopefully some helpful information about why the strike is happening and why it affects this podcast! Linktree including sign up sheet to be on the podcast and our Discord server: https://linktr.ee/SupernaturalOpinionsPodcast SAG-AFTRA…

KJ, Meredith, August (Saving People Queering Things), and Beth (Raising Winchesters) are here to talk about everyone’s favorite dad-Bobby Singer. KJ tells an anecdote about unmonitored internet access during their childhood, and tries to convince the squad that Bobby should’ve murdered John Winchester and kept his children. It’s the first look at D…

KJ, Meredith, and Whiskey are REALLY excited to talk about witches. So excited that EVERYONE has something to share in this week’s mythology section. In other news, Dean and Ruby have finally met, Sam drives an irreparable wedge between himself and his brother, and KJ weighs the pros and cons of selling their soul for witchcraft. CW Episode Descrip…

KJ and Meredith are joined by KJ’s Series of Opinions cohost Moira and Mary (Carrying Wayward) to talk about Supernatural, as well as another show that aired a pilot on September 13, 2005-Bones. Based on the life and crime fiction novels of Kathy Reichs, Bones is a crime procedural that follows Dr. Temperance Brennan and her team of scientists in h…

KJ and Meredith are hosting a slightly emotionally damaging holiday party with Jordan and Jeremy (Monster of the Week and Still His Kingdom Keeps). Small Sam and Dean are being neglected by John (big surprise), and Adult Sam and Dean are facing down their last Christmas together. Our monsters this week are frighteningly polite but that doesn’t stop…

KJ and Meredith are joined by long-time guest Frances, as well as Meredith’s sister Audrey for the conclusion of Gordon’s storyline. If we had a nickel for every time a former Buffy actress played a vampire in a Gordon episode, we’d have two nickels, which isn’t a lot, but it’s weird that this time KJ’s seen all of BTVS. It’s also a Bela episode, a…

KJ and Meredith team up with Driver Picks The Podcast and Thief Steals the Podcast co-hosts Beth and Jamie to talk about Bela (and probably also the rest of this episode, if there’s time left over). There’s cross-continental education on the term “Sheila”, public water fountains, international minimum wage, as well as rock salt bullet physics, Sam’…

Despite gathering some lovers of fairytales, this episode failed to impress KJ or their guests-Meredith, Nick, and Audrey. However Meredith did give us a great lesson on the Grim Brothers, everyone writes a happy ending for two characters most harmed in the course of this episode, and Audrey and KJ do double-takes at the Demi Lovato look-alike in t…

KJ, Meredith, Nick, and August (Saving People, Queering Things and Wayward Parents) team up to talk about character deaths. Along the way they try to remember the many, MANY, ways Sam and Dean Winchester have shuffled off this mortal coil. Turns out-it’s ACTUALLY hard to remember how many times a member of Team Free Will has bit the dust. Also we t…

KJ and Meredith are continuing their way though season three, hoping to one day reach a season with Castiel in it-so they’re joined by Ella and Ilse from The Cas Cast-a Supernatural podcast all about Castiel. In the absence of Castiel, the team is left to discuss Sam’s awkward B&E, and the very important question of where does the sulphur left behi…

With season 2 of Bridgewater just days away, KJ is sending us back in time to when season one of Bridgewater had just ended and reuploading Discussion 5: The One With The Bridgewater Triangle for anyone who wants/needs a little refresher on what happened in Hockomock Swamp and Freetown Forest all those years ago. KJ's on taking a break from Superna…

Today’s topic is good luck vs bad luck, and KJ and Meredith are lucky enough to be joined by podcasting duo Beth and Jamie of Driver Picks The Podcast (and Thief Steals The Podcast, and in Beth’s case, KJ’s cohost on Wayward Parents). There’s a new recurring character this week and KJ’s bisexual thirst-ometer is getting some off the charts readings…

A full house of Supernatural podcasters this week! And, while everyone on this episode CLAIMED to be a Dean-is-Ben’s-father truther, this episode turned into a Mamma Mia situation when the group gathered up three potential candidates to be Ben’s father. It’s finally Meredith’s week to talk about changelings, Jeremy threatens to walk out over the MV…

This week, KJ has compiled some scary stories acquired during past recordings, and through our podcast email and discord server. Some of the guests shared local legends from their hometowns, others shared personal encounters with the other side! Grab a handful of candy to munch on and settle in! See KJ's ghost hunting adventure with CHAPS here: htt…

New season, same podcast! KJ, Meredith, and Ella (The Cas Cast) are recapping and discussing The Magnificent Seven. Sam, Dean, Bobby, and one Mysterious Blondie of the Night are up against the seven deadly sins, Dean’s hurting everyone’s feelings (including ours) by being flippant about his impending death. And everyone struggles with the mouth-fee…

KJ and Meredith are getting an education on fan fiction from repeat guest and fanfic author Jenn and Professor Alpha themself-Berklie, aka @icaruspendragon. Jenn tells us a bit about her Supernatural rewrite fic, heard from your mother (she don’t recognize you)- which is over half a million words (but she has a summary version available for those w…

KJ and Meredith take a minute (47 of them, actually) to reflect on the second season of Supernatural-deaths, secrets, and demon deals as well as look ahead to some of the things coming in Season 3. Additionally some running statistics are analysed (it is NOT looking good for the Bechdel test, friends), and a minor plug for KJ’s The Winchesters podc…

Back to finish the job, KJ, Meredith, and Jordan are together again to watch helplessly as Dean sells his soul, and heckle John’s ghost. KJ is perplexed by the existence of Jake in this narrative but has eyes on the Winchester’s post-resurrection feast, Sam is rising from the dead, Dean is exhibiting an acute mental health crisis, and Meredith, KJ,…